6 Ways to Deal with a Poor Performing Team Member

Here is How You Should Go About it..

1. Recognize the symptoms

Are you sensing a sharp drop in morale coupled with exhaustion and mental fatigue? Or a drop in work performance, an unwillingness to take on new work? If this is an employee who has spent a few years in your organization and almost a decade in the industry, you could have a case of mid-career crisis on your hands. 

2. Talk, try & find out the cause

Be honest, and tell your team member that you’ve noticed a drop in job performance. He/she may react badly to this, given they are already under tremendous pressure, so remain calm in the face of his/her reaction. Talk gently and try to find out the real cause.

3. Don’t speak, listen

Put your preconceived notions aside and listen carefully to what he/she has to say. Identify key words or phrases that are indicative of unhappiness and quiz him/her closely on them. Ensure that you do not come across as annoying or insensitive. 

4. Offer help 

Based on your own experience, assess what is the need of the hour. Does the employee need time off for rest and relaxation? Is he/she looking for new challenges at work? 

Offer whatever help you can. Sit down with the employee and explain he/she is a valuable resource to your team and the company. Discuss his/her professional role. What does he/she love or hate about job? Revaluate the work profile and if possible, try and include more of the work that he/she enjoys. 

Remember, not to encroach on an employee’s personal space. 

5. Up skill the employee

If you believe that the monotony of daily work is largely responsible for the slump, consider recommending him/her for a more challenging task. Alternatively, figure out training needs to upgrade his/her skills. If the employee has been overlooked for a promotion, and you think he/she deserves; you can consider batting for it now.

6. Measure progress 

You can do all these things for a team member, but all your efforts will come to nothing if there is no progress on the ground. So set targets — small ones at first — to assess whether there has been any progress in employee engagement. Monitor his/her work and be sure to share feedback.

Key Takeaways

• Be supportive while sharing your feedback
• Communicate to identify any underlying issues causing problems
• If the problem isn’t work-related but impacts performance on the job, suggest ways they can get help 
• Set goals, up skill or change the job profile to help employees re-engage
• Track progress, share feedback

FAQ on Dealing With Poor Performing Team Member

Q:1 How can a poor performing team member impact overall team productivity?

A: A poor performing team member can have a significant impact on overall team productivity. Their lack of contribution or subpar work can slow down progress, create bottlenecks, and demotivate other team members. It can ultimately lead to missed deadlines, decreased quality of work, and hindered team performance as a whole.

Q:2 What are the potential reasons for a team member’s poor performance?

A: Several reasons can contribute to a team member’s poor performance. It could be due to a lack of necessary skills or knowledge, personal issues affecting their work, insufficient training or resources, unclear expectations or goals, or a mismatch between their strengths and assigned tasks.

Q:3 How should I address a poor performing team member?

A: When addressing a poor performing team member, it’s important to approach the situation with empathy and a desire to understand the underlying causes. Start by having an open and honest conversation, providing constructive feedback, and offering support or additional training if needed. Set clear expectations, establish performance goals, and monitor progress closely to help the team member improve.

Q:4 Should I involve other team members when dealing with a poor performer?

A: Involving other team members when dealing with a poor performer should be approached with caution. While it can be helpful to gather feedback or insights from the team, it’s crucial to maintain confidentiality and professionalism. Encourage open communication but be mindful of maintaining a positive team dynamic and avoiding unnecessary conflicts or tensions.

Q:5 What if efforts to improve a team member’s performance are unsuccessful?

A: If your efforts to help a poor performing team member improve their performance are unsuccessful, it may be necessary to consider other options. This could involve reassigning tasks, providing additional training or mentorship, or in extreme cases, exploring disciplinary measures or reevaluating their fit within the team. It’s important to involve HR or management when making such decisions to ensure fairness and adherence to company policies.